New York Yankees captain Aaron Judge’s third American League MVP Award, won in November 2025 by a 355-335 margin over Cal Raleigh, settled the baseball argument for another year. The argument a Yankees analyst wants to have is about everything else the captain does.
In a video segment of Pinstripe Territory, posted to YouTube, the analyst called Aaron Judge a “larger-than-life figure” and a three-time MVP before turning to what he sees as the captain’s flaw. He said:
